Stadium: Madison Square Garden Round: 1
Home Manager: Mike Anderson Away Manager: Kevin Willard
| NCAAB | 2019/02/24 01:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | L | 70-78 |
| NCAAB | 2018/12/30 01:30 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | W | 74-76 |
| NCAAB | 2018/02/24 17:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 81-74 |
| NCAAB | 2017/12/31 22:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | W | 70-75 |
| NCAAB | 2017/02/11 17:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | L | 70-78 |
| NCAAB | 2017/01/22 17:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | W | 73-86 |
| NCAAB | 2016/02/21 17:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | W | 61-62 |
| NCAAB | 2016/01/28 00:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 79-60 |
| NCAAB | 2015/02/21 17:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | L | 85-72 |
| NCAAB | 2014/12/31 17:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 78-67 |
| NCAAB | 2012/02/14 12:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 94-64 |
| NCAAB | 2011/03/03 12:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 84-70 |
| NCAAB | 2010/02/17 12:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | W | 50-59 |
| NCAAB | 2009/02/22 12:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | L | 70-65 |
| NCAAB | 2009/02/05 12:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 91-81 |
| NCAAB | 2008/03/01 12:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | L | 65-62 |
| NCAAB | 2007/01/11 12:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 79-63 |
| NCAAB | 2006/02/21 12:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | L | 58-47 |
| NCAAB | 2006/01/04 12:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 69-61 |
| NCAAB | 2005/02/12 12:00 | Seton Hall v St. Johns | W | 57-55 |
| NCAAB | 2005/01/29 12:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | W | 55-62 |
| NCAAB | 2004/01/10 12:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | W | 54-71 |
| NCAAB | 2003/01/04 12:00 | St. Johns v Seton Hall | L | 74-66 |